|
Introduction
On the Avisoft site is an impressive list of recorders with some important features. If you carefully review this list, you will quickly come to the conclusion that many of the recorders mentioned are no longer available and that some recorders are missing. This kind of defeats the purpose of the list. It is doubtful whether the criteria mentioned there are sufficient for the choice of a recorder for field work. There are more criteria that are important to make field recording a success. So I made my own list of criteria and it looks a little different.
Criteria that a recorder for field work must meet
- input stages with sufficient gain
- input stages with very low own noise
- manual level controls that are directly accessible during recording
- start recording with one button
- must have clear level meters
- level meters with background lighting for dark environments, but also readable in the bright sun
- provided with XLR connections
- a headphone connection with sufficient power
- uncompressed recordings in the WAV format due to software compatibility
- no special software required to transfer recordings to a computer
- write data on standard (SD) memory cards
- low weight
- low power consumption
- work on readily available batteries
- can be worn over the shoulder for mobility
|
|
Tascam DR-701D Recorder (n.a.)
|
Table
The table below contains recorders that can be carried over the shoulder, with or without a bag. The connections are often on the side. There are also only recorders with a meaningful number of channels. Someone needs to explain to me again what, if you have to stay mobile, you are going to do with an 8 channel recorder in the open field. There are more recorder types that meet the list and have a meaningful number of channels, but are often difficult or impossible to carry over the shoulder. Many of those recorders have fixed microphones on one side and XLR inputs on the other.
Recorders that meet the above requirements, but that does not mean that all are equally suitable. The data comes from the manufacturer's specifications;
| Brand/Type |
XLR |
Noise (EIN) |
Gain |
32-bit float |
Level reg. |
Peak hold |
Headphones |
SD |
Weight |
Max. con- sumption |
Battery |
Number |
Operating time in minutes |
| SoundDevices MixPre-3 (II) |
3 |
-128 dBu |
70 dB |
yes |
yes |
no |
2x 300mW |
max. 512Gb |
480gr. |
max.6W(?) |
AA |
4 |
Alkaline 40m, NiHM 140m, Lithium 225m |
| SoundDevices MixPre-6 (II) |
4 |
-128 dBu |
70 dB |
yes |
yes |
no |
2x 300mW |
max. 512Gb |
560gr. |
max.6W(?) |
AA |
4 |
Alkaline 40m, NiHM 140m, Lithium 225m |
| Tascam DR-40XP (handheld) |
4 |
-126 dBu |
89 dB |
yes |
yes |
no |
2x 20mW |
64Mb/ 512Gb |
282gr |
max.1,7W |
AA |
3 |
Alkaline 300m, NiHM 300m, Lithium 600m |
| Tascam DR-70D |
4 |
-120 dBu |
72 dB |
no |
yes |
yes |
2x 20mW |
64Mb/ 128Gb |
530gr |
max.5W |
AA |
4 |
Alkaline 360m, NiHM 375m, NiHM pro 465m |
| Tascam FR-AV2 |
2 |
-127 dBu |
80 dB |
yes |
yes |
no |
2x 50mW |
64Mb/ 512Gb |
267gr |
max.3,8W |
AA |
3 |
Alkaline 270m, NiHM 330m, Lithium 600m |
| Tascam FR-AV4 |
4 |
-127 dBu |
80 dB |
yes |
yes |
yes, adj. |
2x 50mW |
64Mb/ 512Gb |
756gr |
max.5,4W |
AA |
4 |
Alkaline 150m, NiHM 180m, Lithium 390m |
| Zoom F3 |
2 |
-127 dBu |
n.b. |
yes |
no |
no |
2x 50mW |
16Mb/ 1Tb |
242gr. |
5W |
AA |
2 |
Alkaline 120m, NiHM 180m, Lithium 450m |
|
|
Tascam FR-AV2 Recorder
|
Explanation criteria
Explanation of the criteria that a fieldwork recorder must meet;
- input stages with sufficient gain
Many of the microphones used have a low voltage output. In addition, the sounds to be recorded often only just exceed the ambient noise. It is then necessary that the microphone amplifier has sufficient amplification to lift the sound above the noise floor.
- input stages with very low noise
It is of course not intended that the microphone amplifier adds noise to the recordings. Unfortunately it is not that easy to compare all recorders at this point. The simplest method is to compare the EIN specifications. The abbreviation EIN stands for Equivalent Input Noise. The value is expressed in dBu and the lower the value the better.
- manual level controls that are directly accessible during recording
There must be controls on the recorder that can directly control the level of the input signal. This prevents the signal from being recorded distorted if suddenly the sound to be recorded becomes much stronger. Immediate intervention is then necessary. Somewhere deep in a menu with many steps is not a good solution.
- start recording with one button
Before actually recording, you must be able to start the recorder with one button. With the digital memory card recorders, this is immediately. A pre-recording memory is therefore not necessary, this feature was useful if several buttons had to be pressed to record and some mechanical system had to be set in motion. All these delays have now been eliminated with the memory card recorders.
- must have clear level meters
There must be level meters that clearly show the level of the sound to be recorded. In addition, there must be indications that indicate how far that level is on the meter. The level meter must have a peak indication in order to follow the signal properly. A VU meter indication does not display the peaks but the average level, there must then be a peak indication on top of the VU indication. Sometimes there is a peak hold available and sometimes this is also adjustable.
- level meters with background lighting for dark environments, but also readable in the bright sun
Many recordings in the open field take place at a time when, for example, nature is just waking up. It is then just twilight and even then level meters must be easy to read. Adjustable lighting is then a requirement. If the sun shines, these meters must still be easy to read, also think of reflective meter window(s).
- provided with XLR connections
Almost all professional(?) microphones have an XLR connection. This is a robust connection that ensures that the forces exerted by the cable are transferred to the housing and not to the contacts as with the 6.3mm jack and 3.5mm mini jack.
- a headphone connection with sufficient power
Because sound is recorded with microphones, a headphone connection must be present to be able to check the sound to be recorded. Checking through a built-in speaker increases the chance of an effect known as acoustic feedback. Almost all current headphones have a 3.5mm mini jack plug. Other types of plugs occur, an adapter cable must then be used. The headphone connection must provide sufficient power. How much power is highly dependent on the headphones to be connected. Less sensitive types <95 dB/mW require more power.
- uncompressed recordings in the WAV format due to software compatibility
Almost all software programs can process the WAV format. Other formats are often subject to licenses and/or contain compression techniques.
- no special software required to transfer recordings to a computer
The recorder must be able to connect to the computer with a cable and the contents of the memory card must be able to transfer to the computer's hard disk without any problems. In most cases these days it is a USB connection. Note that many computers no longer have a USB 2.x port, while this is often standard on recorders. On some computers and some USB 3.x ports, the USB 3.x appears not to be backwards compatible, while this should be in accordance with the specifications.
- write data on standard (SD) memory cards
Any (SD) memory card that meets the specifications of the recorder must be usable. Recording all channels in the highest sampling frequencies requires a very fast (SD) memory card. There are already signals that the highest sampling frequency in multi-channel technology gives problems with even the fastest (SD) cards.
- low weight
You have to carry it along for a long time ...
- low power consumption
Low power consumption also means less consumption of batteries.
- work on readily available batteries
The above recorders can all work on the well-known penlight or AA battery. This battery can be purchased in various qualities. Lithium is preferred and lasts much longer than Alkaline due to the higher power consumption.
- can be worn over the shoulder for mobility
By wearing the recording set on your shoulder you have two hands free. The buttons and meters are on top and can be operated or read directly.
Okay, now what?
Using the above list, you must determine whether all of this applies to your situation. So you're going to make your own list. Then you search the internet for recorder manufacturers. If you see an interesting model, try to download its technical data and manual. The technical data to compare models, the manual to find out whether the recorder can do what you want. Unfortunately, in this case, more expensive is not always better. Digital technology has made recorders a lot more complex than recorders from about 20 to 30 years ago. The digital is often solved by a chipset, a number of integrated electronic circuits that work together. What makes digital recorders more complex is the control from the software. This requires additional electronics. The software may contain errors that can only be repaired by the manufacturer. The manufacturer must therefore be a reliable partner and unfortunately there are no guarantees in this turbulent market that the manufacturer will not go bankrupt or stop supporting the model prematurely. Highly respected manufacturers are also launching new models of recorders that cause problems in all kinds of areas. So it is useful before you buy a recorder to consult various forums (e.g. http://taperssection.com/index.php). You will then quickly gain insight if your choice does have all sorts of unwanted problems.
If problems are mentioned you have to put them in a certain rank. A menu with many options before you can set anything is less serious than if there are continuous problems with the storage medium or freezing the entire recorder with the only way out switching off and on again. Only then you often lose everything because the storage medium was not properly closed. And there are more things that you need to think about very carefully.
Recording or playing time
Not much has changed compared to analogue systems up to and including pre-digital systems such as DCC. With the analogue systems, the tape had a limited recording time, the cassette or minidisc had a certain playing time. And it is still that way today, the storage media only has a certain recording time which depends on a number of settings and the number of channels. Yet things are different today. On an analogue recorder it is no problem to make a recording of several hours and listen to it that way. With storage media you face two limitations. The storage medium itself is only available in certain sizes and/or the recorder only supports a certain size. The latter often has to do with rights, i.e. money. In addition, the files cannot become infinitely large. Long recordings are, automatically or not, divided over multiple files. You often need additional equipment, usually a computer, to put the files together and even then, they often cannot be saved as one file due to the limitations of the OS or programs used.
revision October 24 2026
| |